A similar websites finder is only as good as the way it decides what "similar" means. Some count shared searches, some read buyer behaviour, some lean on a model's memory. We scored six common methods on four things that decide whether the list is worth acting on, and ranked them.

How we scored

Each method gets 0 to 3 points in four columns, for a maximum of 12.

  • Measurable: does it give numbers you can compare, or just names?
  • Filters noise: does it keep giant general sites and one-off mentions out of the top?
  • Repeatable: run it again tomorrow, do you get the same list?
  • Cost: 3 for free, lower as the price rises.

The leaderboard

Rank Method Measurable Filters noise Repeatable Cost Total
1 seogeoaeo.ai Competitor Finder 3 3 3 1 10
2 Quoted two-brand search 1 2 2 3 8
3 Independent alternatives roundups 0 2 2 3 7
4 Google autocomplete 0 1 1 3 5
5 AI assistant, asked once 0 0 0 3 3
6 related: operator 0 0 0 3 3

The scores are our judgment from how each method works, not a lab test.

1. seogeoaeo.ai Competitor Finder (10 of 12)

Enter any public domain and a Google country. Competitor Finder compares its ranking keywords against other sites and returns up to 30 domains that share the most. Each row shows the shared keyword count, the site's own keyword total, estimated monthly visits and average rank.

It wins the noise column outright. Instead of ranking by raw shared count, which favours huge sites, it checks what share of each site's keywords overlap. Five percent or more makes a close competitor. Large general sites are listed apart. Same input, same data, same list, so it repeats well.

It loses points on cost: 38 credits a run, with plans from $29 a month for 2,000 credits. And it only measures Google search overlap, so rivals that win through ads or offline sales are invisible to it. Visits are estimates.

2. Quoted two-brand search (8)

Search for two known peers in quotes and read the pages that mention both. The extra names that recur are the cluster. It filters noise reasonably well because a page naming both peers is usually on topic. It gives no numbers and takes a while.

3. Independent alternatives roundups (7)

Read several third-party "alternatives to X" articles and keep names that appear in three or more. Throw out vendor-written lists. Free and fairly stable, but roundups age and borrow from each other.

4. Google autocomplete (5)

Type the brand and "vs". Google says predictions reflect real searches, which makes this a real signal of what buyers compare. It loses points for drifting with location and time and for giving no sense of how close two brands are.

5. AI assistant, asked once (3)

One question to ChatGPT, Perplexity or Gemini gives a fluent list, but answers change between sessions. Asked once it scores near the bottom. Asked several times across all three, keeping only brands named every run, it would climb several places, since repetition fixes most of its noise.

Google's current search operator page lists site:, filetype:, imagesize: and src:, and not related:. Free, but you cannot build on a shortcut Google no longer documents.

What the ranking does not settle

The top method measures one kind of similarity: shared searches. If your goal is pricing or positioning, buyer-based methods like autocomplete and roundups matter more than their scores suggest. If you want daily movement in rankings, nothing on this board does it; seogeoaeo.ai has no rank tracker, and a tracking suite is the better buy.

Bottom line

For a list you can defend with numbers, start at the top of the table with seogeoaeo.ai. Add the free methods in second and third place to catch the rivals that keyword data cannot see.