The best SEO score checker is the one whose number you can trace back to specific fixes. On that test, seogeoaeo.ai takes first place: it publishes how its score is built and ties every lost point to a fix on a named page. Lighthouse in PageSpeed Insights is the best free pick for one page, and the health scores inside Ahrefs and Semrush suit teams that already use those suites.
How this leaderboard works
SEO scores do not compare across tools. Each vendor chooses its own checks and its own math, and Google does not publish an SEO score for your site. So this list ranks the checkers, not their numbers. Each one was judged on three things:
- Transparency. Can you see how the score is calculated?
- Actionability. Does each lost point lead to a specific fix?
- Tracking. Can you watch the score move after you ship a change?
The ranking at a glance
| Rank | Checker | Score it gives | Cost to start | What it scores |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | seogeoaeo.ai website check | SEO readiness, AEO readiness, AI access, overall (0 to 100) | Free home page preview | The pages you pick |
| 2 | Lighthouse in PageSpeed Insights | SEO category (0 to 100) | Free | One page per run |
| 3 | Ahrefs Free Site Audit | Health Score | Free for verified sites | The site |
| 4 | Semrush Site Audit | Site Health Score | 100 pages a month without an SEO Toolkit plan | The site |
1. seogeoaeo.ai website check
You get four scores from 0 to 100: SEO readiness, AEO readiness, AI access and an overall figure. The bands match PageSpeed Insights, with 90 and up green and under 50 red. The scoring rules are published on the seogeoaeo.ai blog: every check starts at 100 and loses points for each fix it finds, with high-priority fixes costing far more than low ones. An open high-priority problem keeps the score at 89 or lower, so a site with a blocked home page cannot sit in the green.
Every point lost maps to a fix in one list sorted by priority. Run the check again after publishing and the report shows the percent of issues fixed and how each score changed. The preview of your home page is free with no account, and the full home page check costs 67 credits. It does not score rankings or backlinks.
2. Lighthouse SEO score in PageSpeed Insights
Free from Google, no account, at pagespeed.web.dev or in Chrome DevTools. The SEO category is one of four Lighthouse scores, alongside Performance, Accessibility and Best Practices, and 90 or more counts as good. It is built from pass or fail audits such as the HTTP status code, meta description, canonical tag, robots.txt and link text.
It is transparent, since every audit is documented. The catch is scope: it rates one page per run, so a 100 means that page passed the basics, not that the site is in good shape.
3. Ahrefs Free: a health score for verified sites
Ahrefs Webmaster Tools, now called Ahrefs Free, includes a Site Audit for verified sites that looks for more than 170 technical and on-page issues. You can follow the Health Score over time, which is useful for spotting a bad release across the whole site. It needs an account and proof of ownership.
4. Semrush Site Audit: the site health score
Semrush's Site Audit runs more than 140 checks and reports a Site Health Score. Without an SEO Toolkit subscription it crawls 100 pages a month, so it ranks last here for anyone not already paying for Semrush.
Honorable mention: Google Search Console
Search Console gives no score at all. It is still the one free source of Google's own data: which pages are indexed, the queries that find you, clicks, impressions and average position. Use it to check whether a better score turned into better results.
The verdict
For a score you can explain and act on, start with the seogeoaeo.ai website check, then use Lighthouse for quick single-page checks. If your site has thousands of pages and you already pay for Ahrefs or Semrush, their site-wide health scores are the better fit for a full crawl.