We ranked four keyword gap analysis tools on the job most people bring to them: find the searches a competitor wins in Google that your site misses, and turn them into a to-do list. Scores are out of 10 on four measures, and the total decides the order. Prices are from each vendor's own page in October 2026.
The standings
| Rank | Tool | Gap output | Cost to start | Ease of acting on it | Fit for occasional use | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | seogeoaeo.ai Keyword Gap | 8 | 10 | 9 | 10 | 37 |
| 2 | Semrush Keyword Gap | 10 | 5 | 8 | 5 | 28 |
| 3 | Ahrefs Content Gap | 9 | 5 | 7 | 5 | 26 |
| 4 | Google Search Console | 3 | 10 | 6 | 7 | 26 |
Search Console ties with Ahrefs on points and sits fourth because it cannot show a competitor's keywords at all, which is the point of the exercise.
1. seogeoaeo.ai Keyword Gap: 37 points
seogeoaeo.ai wins on everything except breadth. You give it your site, one rival and one of 20 countries. It returns up to the 300 most searched keywords the rival ranks for and you do not, cut to those where the rival holds a top-20 spot, so each term already sends it traffic.
Why it scores high on acting: the report does the sorting most people do by hand. It marks the easiest terms by difficulty, splits informational searches into a blog topics list with the rival's brand left out, separates terms worth bidding on with their cost per click, and names the rival pages that collect the most gap terms. Those pages are your briefs.
Cost: 85 credits per run, shown before it starts. The Indie plan is $29 a month for 2,000 credits, enough for 23 runs. If the data provider has no record of the two sites, the run is refunded.
Where it loses points: one competitor per run, and only the missing set. It does not show keywords where you both rank and you trail.
2. Semrush Keyword Gap: 28 points
The most complete gap report of the four. It compares up to five domains side by side, works on organic, paid or Google Shopping keywords, and labels every term as shared, missing, weak, strong, untapped or unique. You can compare subfolders and single URLs on the Guru or Business toolkits.
It scores lower on cost and occasional use because it lives inside a subscription. The SEO plan is $139 a month, or $117.33 a month billed yearly. If your team runs gap reports every week across several rivals, this is the better tool and the ranking flips.
3. Ahrefs Content Gap: 26 points
Ahrefs describes it as finding the keywords your competitors rank for and you do not, across several competitors at once. Its useful filter shows terms that any rival ranks for, at least a set number of rivals rank for, or all of them rank for. Terms every rival wins are a strong signal.
Ahrefs lists Lite at $129 a month, with annual billing saving up to 17%. We could not confirm from the pricing page which plan includes Content Gap, so check before you buy. It scores a little below Semrush on output because its product page does not describe a weak set, only the keywords you lack.
4. Google Search Console: 26 points
Free, and measured rather than estimated. The Performance report gives your own queries, clicks, impressions and average position. That makes it the best source for the weak set: queries where you rank on page two behind someone else.
It scores 3 on gap output because it sees only your site. Use it alongside a gap tool, never instead of one.
How we would use the top of the table
- Pick the rival that outranks you most often for buying searches. If you are unsure, seogeoaeo.ai's Competitor Finder lists the sites sharing the most keywords with yours for 38 credits.
- Run Keyword Gap on seogeoaeo.ai for that rival in your main market.
- Pull the weak set from Search Console.
- Drop brand terms and anything off-intent, then brief the rival pages that win the most terms.
A note on accuracy
seogeoaeo.ai states plainly that its search volumes and difficulty scores are estimates, and Search Console is the only tool here reporting your own measured positions. Treat any volume figure as a way to rank keywords against each other, not as a forecast of traffic.