A competitor analysis matrix template turns a pile of rival data into a ranking. Rows are sites, columns are the measures that decide who wins in search, and once every cell is filled you can rank each column and see which rival leads where. The trick is that a matrix only ranks fairly when every number in a column comes from the same place.
Build the grid
Start with five rows at most: your own site on top, then the three to five rivals that matter. Twelve columns cover what decides search visibility:
- Site
- Role (search, sales or both)
- Organic visits per month
- Keywords, with the count in the top 10
- Top pages
- Shared keywords
- Gap keywords
- Referring domains
- Content types
- Google Ads
- Social ads
- AI citations
The seogeoaeo.ai template gives these as a table and as a CSV that opens in Sheets or Excel, with the keyword count split into two numeric columns and a link rank column added so everything sorts.
A filled matrix to rank
The source article fills the grid for an invented dental-booking app, Northfold, with made-up round numbers on .example domains, a suffix reserved for documentation. Here is part of it.
| Site | Role | Visits/mo | Referring domains | AI citations |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| northfold.example | You | 2,000 | 150 | Not cited |
| chairtime.example | Both | 20,000 | 900 | 15% |
| clinicplanner.example | Both | 8,000 | 400 | 5% |
| toothtalk.example | Search | 60,000 | 3,000 | 25% |
| bigpractice.example | Sales | 1,000 | 1,000 | Not cited |
Read the leaderboard per column
Rank each column on its own and the leaders change.
Traffic. Toothtalk, a trade magazine, leads by a wide margin. It sells nothing Northfold sells, so first place here says little about the market Northfold competes in.
Links. Toothtalk again, then Bigpractice, which has more referring domains than Chairtime but barely any search traffic. Links alone did not win it rankings.
AI citations. Toothtalk at 25%, Chairtime at 15%. Northfold does not appear at all, and in a matrix "Not cited" is a result, not a blank.
Gap keywords. Chairtime leaves Northfold the most ground to make up, 250 keywords, mostly won by a no-show calculator and reminder templates.
The overall winner depends on what you weight. For a product company, Chairtime is the rival to beat: it is marked "both", it is second in traffic and citations, and its pages explain most of the gap. That is why the article's first decision is to build two tool pages aimed at Chairtime's gap keywords.
Fill the scores from one source per column
A matrix built from five tools produces a fake ranking, because two providers never agree on a site's traffic. Pick one source per column and use it for your own row too.
On seogeoaeo.ai the matrix maps onto single-purpose tools, each priced in credits:
- Competitor Finder (38 credits) picks the rows and counts shared keywords; it lists the 30 sites that share the most Google keywords with yours.
- Domain Overview (50) fills visits, keywords and referring domains, with a link rank from 0 to 1,000.
- Competitor Keywords (35) fills top pages.
- Keyword Gap (85) fills gap keywords from the 300 most searched ones you are missing.
- Competitor Google Ads (15), Meta Ad Finder (5) and LinkedIn Ad Finder (5) fill the ad columns.
- AI Citation Finder (160) fills the whole citations column in one topic run, with the share of answers that cite each site.
Content types is scored by hand: open each top page and label it guide, template, calculator, comparison page, category page or documentation.
Re-rank every quarter
Rankings in a matrix move for two reasons: rivals change, and data providers revise their estimates. Rerun the same tools each quarter and only call a shift real when it holds across two refreshes. If you want positions tracked daily between refreshes, that is a rank tracker's job, and seogeoaeo.ai does not have one; a suite such as Semrush does. For a quarterly leaderboard of your rivals, a full row costs about 195 credits, and the $29 Indie plan includes 2,000 a month.