The cleanest way to compare competitor SEO is to treat it like a league table. Put your site and four rivals in rows, give each column one measurable thing, and rank everyone column by column. You will not get a single winner, and that is the point: the table shows where each rival leads and where the gaps are small enough to close.

This guide sets up that scoreboard, explains how to read it, and shows what the data costs to fill. Figures and prices are from seogeoaeo.ai's tool pages, checked in October 2026.

Who gets a row

Five rows: you plus three to five search rivals. A search rival is any domain that keeps appearing on page one for the searches you care about, which can include a review site or a trade magazine. Leave out the giants that rank for everything, like Wikipedia; they would top every column and teach you nothing.

To pick the rows with data rather than a hunch, Competitor Finder (38 credits) lists the 30 sites that share the most Google keywords with yours, with each site's overlap share. Sites where at least 5% of their keywords overlap with yours are flagged as close competitors. Those are your rows.

The columns

Each column should be something you can measure the same way for every row, from the same source.

Column What it shows Where it comes from
Keyword overlap How much of a rival's keyword list you share Competitor Finder
Ranking keywords How many keywords the domain ranks for, split by position Domain Overview
Estimated search visits Monthly Google visits, as estimated Domain Overview
Link rank A 0 to 1,000 score for how many and how strong the linking sites are Domain Overview or Backlink Finder
Top page format What kind of page earns the most traffic Competitor Keywords
Technical pass Status, title and H1, content without JavaScript, mobile speed Single page checks
AI citations How many AI answers cite the domain AI Citation Finder

Domain Overview (50 credits) fills four columns in one run: keyword count by position, estimated visits and their ad value, linking sites and link rank. That makes it the workhorse of the scoreboard.

How to rank

Rank each column separately, 1 to 5. Do not add the ranks into a total. A rival that is first on links and fifth on AI citations is a different problem from one that is third on everything, and a combined score hides that.

Read the board in three passes:

  1. Where are you last? That column is either your biggest weakness or something that does not matter for your business. Decide which.
  2. Where is the gap to the rank above you small? Small gaps are where a quarter of work moves you up. A rival at ninth position for a search you want is a small gap; one at second is not.
  3. Who leads columns nobody else does? A rival that tops AI citations but sits mid-table in Google is doing something specific. Open the pages that get cited and read what they say near the top.

A note on the numbers

Every visits, keywords and link figure in this table is a provider estimate. That is fine for a league table, because you are comparing rows from one source rather than reporting exact counts. It stops being fine if you mix sources: a rival measured in one link index and you in another will not line up, since each index misses different links.

What it costs to fill the board

For you plus four rivals on seogeoaeo.ai:

  • Competitor Finder, once: 38 credits
  • Domain Overview for five domains: 250 credits
  • Competitor Keywords for four rivals: 140 credits
  • AI Citation Finder for each of the five domains: 800 credits

That is 1,228 credits, inside the 2,000 on the $29 Indie plan. If you only need AI citations at topic level rather than per domain, one run covers the topic for 160 credits and the total drops to 588. Add a few page checks at 5 to 20 credits each for the technical column. Each tool shows its price before running, and a failed run is refunded.

The AI Citation Finder counts answers from Google AI Overviews and ChatGPT only. Perplexity and Gemini are outside it.

Turn the table into moves

A scoreboard is a means, not an output. Finish with three or four actions, each tied to a column where you can climb, with an owner and a date. Then refill the board next quarter and compare the ranks.

One limit to know: seogeoaeo.ai takes snapshots. It does not track positions day by day. If you want a live chart of ranks moving between quarterly scoreboards, a rank tracker from Semrush or Ahrefs covers that job. For the full method behind the board, see seogeoaeo.ai's step-by-step competitor analysis.