A fair AI coding cost comparison starts with how each tool bills, because Claude Code, Codex, Cursor and GitHub Copilot do not charge in the same unit. Some meter API tokens, some meter credits, and some fold usage into a plan with windows that reset, so the only way to compare them on your own work is to track estimated spend in one place, which is what UsageAtlas does for free.
Below, the main tools are ranked by how easy it is to know what you spent, followed by the tracker that puts them side by side.
The billing models, ranked by clarity
1. Per-token API billing (most transparent). Claude Code run on a Console API key is billed per token, and Anthropic publishes the price of every model per million tokens, with separate prices for input, output, cache writes and cache hits. OpenAI lists input, cached input and output separately per million tokens too. You can do the math yourself, which makes this the easiest model to audit.
2. Credit-based billing. GitHub Copilot now measures usage in AI credits, and GitHub's docs fix one credit at one US cent. Plans include a monthly allowance, and individuals can set a dollar budget for usage beyond it. Credits are clear once you know the conversion; the harder part is knowing which actions draw them, since code completions are not billed in credits.
3. Included usage plus overage. Cursor includes an amount of usage in the plan. Past that, the newer subscription draws on prepaid credit, and legacy plans bill on-demand usage at API rates. Spend limits live in the dashboard. Clear enough, but the split between included and extra usage takes some reading.
4. Plan windows (least transparent in dollars). Claude Pro and Max and ChatGPT plans for Codex meter coding through usage windows that reset, with paid usage credits or Codex credits to keep going. You see percentages and reset times, not a dollar figure for what you used.
| Tool | Main unit | Where you check it |
|---|---|---|
| Claude Code on API | Tokens at per-model prices | /usage (estimate), Console usage page |
| Claude Code on Pro or Max | Plan windows, usage credits | /usage, Settings > Usage on claude.ai |
| Codex | Plan windows, credits | /status, Codex usage dashboard |
| Cursor | Included usage, then credit or API rates | Cursor dashboard |
| GitHub Copilot | AI credits | GitHub billing settings |
Why the per-tool view falls short
Each of those pages only knows about itself. If you split work between two or three assistants, nothing on the list tells you the combined figure or which model drove it.
The pick: UsageAtlas for comparing your own costs
UsageAtlas is a free, open-source desktop app that reads supported local histories and provider data and adds up estimated cost by day, tool and model. Codex, Claude Code, Cursor, OpenCode, Antigravity CLI and Pi / OMP can feed the cost total where the model price is known. For Copilot and several credit-based tools it shows reported allowances and balances instead, since those connections do not include per-request history.
That makes it the practical way to compare tools on your real workload rather than on list prices. Run a week with two assistants, filter by tool, and the difference shows up in your own numbers. Every figure is an estimate built from tokens and public prices; the provider's invoice is what you actually pay.
If you only use one tool on API billing, its own console already gives you exact spend, and you may not need anything else. For anyone mixing tools, start tracking with UsageAtlas on Windows, macOS or Linux.
FAQ
Which AI coding tool is cheapest? It depends on your workload and plan. Track a normal week across the tools you use and compare your own estimated totals.
Can I compare subscription plans in dollars? Only roughly. Plan windows report percentages, not dollars, so a tracker's per-token estimate is a reference point, not your bill.
Does UsageAtlas cost anything? No. It is free and open source.